Article by Dr Sudhanshu Kumar

On 14 July 2023, Narendra Modi occupied the guest of honour’s position at the Bastille Day parade on the Champs-Elysees in Paris. France’s national day is among the most choreographed ceremonies in the French diplomatic calendar, and the invitation extended to a foreign head of government to sit in that chair carries a signal distinct from an ordinary state visit. Six months later, Emmanuel Macron stood on the dais at Kartavya Path as the chief guest at India’s Republic Day, the sixth French leader to hold that position. In February 2026, the two leaders elevated their countries’ ties to a Special Global Strategic Partnership, anchored by the Horizon 2047 Roadmap.

The progression from the first ceremony to the third is easier to understand when you consider what has been built across the two decades that preceded all three. In the drydocks of Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders in Mumbai, six submarines took shape across two decades of construction, technology transfer, training and sustained industrial partnership. By January 2025, all six Kalvari-class submarines were in service with the Indian Navy. What they represent is not only a bilateral agreement or a defence procurement. They are the most tangible product of a partnership that preceded both summits, preceded the Horizon roadmap, preceded the exchange of ceremonial honours, and whose terms are now being extended for the next twenty-five years on a foundation that two decades of genuine collaboration have made credible.

The Long Approach

India’s ambition to build a new class of submarines under a genuine technology transfer arrangement had been central to naval planning since the late 1990s, and the selection of Naval Group’s Scorpene design represented a judgement that extended beyond the vessel’s technical specifications. France had a documented record of exporting the Scorpene to multiple navies and of honouring the terms of its technology transfer obligations. The arrangement India sought was one in which the recipient’s industrial development would be treated as a genuine objective of the partnership, not merely as a commercial adjunct to the delivery of hardware. This was what the P-75 programme was designed to test, and what the completed Kalvari class has demonstrated.

The P-75 programme called for six Scorpene submarines to be constructed at Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders in Mumbai. The arrangement was structured around a Transfer of Technology agreement under which Naval Group would transfer construction knowledge, training programmes and manufacturing processes to Indian workers and engineers at MDL. The stated ambition of the programme was not merely to deliver six submarines to the Indian Navy. It was to build an institutional capability at Mazagon Dock that would remain after the last hull was launched and the last Naval Group technician had returned to France.

That ambition encountered the full complexity of what submarine construction at this level actually demands. A Scorpene-class submarine is a pressure vessel required to function reliably at depth, in electromagnetic silence, with weapons systems integrated into the hull and crew accommodation designed for extended submerged deployment. The tolerances are measured in fractions of millimetres. The systems integration required between propulsion, sensors, weapons and combat management software is elaborate enough that even established shipyards in experienced nations have faced delays on first-of-class builds. MDL was doing something genuinely demanding, and the delays the programme encountered were evidence of that reality, not of a failed partnership. Naval Group’s teams remained present through those delays, working alongside Indian engineers and technicians across the construction period, through the sea trials, and into the sustainment phase.

What Mazagon Dock Built?

INS Kalvari, the lead vessel of the class, undocked at Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders in 2015. India’s first Scorpene-class submarine and the first to be built at MDL in two decades, INS Kalvari was commissioned into the Indian Navy in December 2017. It was followed by INS Khanderi, INS Karanj, INS Vela, INS Vagir, and finally INS Vagsheer, which completed the class in January 2025.

The Scorpene design that Naval Group brought to India in 2005 was a proven French platform. The submarines built under P-75 incorporated Indian systems and components where the programme’s scope permitted, but the essential architecture remained French in its origin. What is envisaged under P-75 AS represents a rebalancing of that architecture. The design is set to incorporate DRDO technologies developed in India, Indian-origin weapons systems, Indian-developed batteries, an Indian combat management system, and a range of additional components produced by Indian industry. The platform heritage and certain core design elements carry through from the Scorpene lineage, and the internal content of the vessel is being progressively filled with Indian equivalents built on the foundation of knowledge accumulated across the Kalvari programme.

This transition is the logical destination of the technology transfer that began twenty years ago. The purpose of that transfer was never to allow India to build French submarines indefinitely on Indian soil. It was to develop the technical foundation from which India could build submarines with an increasing proportion of Indian content, eventually arriving at a vessel whose critical systems were Indian in design, Indian in manufacture, and Indian in the expertise required to sustain them. P-75 AS represents that destination, or at minimum its point of departure.

The significance of this shift extends beyond the question of which country’s components are inside the hull. A submarine with indigenised critical systems is a sovereign capability. Its essential technologies cannot be embargoed, sanctioned or made unavailable by a supplier country’s foreign policy choices. Its maintenance does not depend on licences requiring periodic renewal under terms set elsewhere. Its crew operates systems they understand because those systems were developed in India, with Indian operational requirements informing their design, by engineers who will continue to support them through the vessel’s service life. When the P-75 AS submarine enters service, it will carry the heritage of the Kalvari class and stand as the natural continuation of the partnership that built it.

Naval Group’s posture toward this indigenisation process is itself instructive. The willingness to work alongside Indian industry and Indian researchers toward an outcome in which India’s domestic content progressively grows is the character of a partnership that is, in the truest sense, unconditional. That word carries weight in a domain where conditionality is the norm.

Policy Assessment

The elevation of India-France ties to a Special Global Strategic Partnership in February 2026, guided by the Horizon 2047 Roadmap, sets a twenty-year frame for a relationship that already has two decades of substantive collaboration behind it. The Scorpene programme, in that context, is both a completed chapter and a template for what comes after.

What the template demonstrates is that successful defence technology transfer between unequal partners is achievable, but only where the supplier treats the recipient’s industrial development as a genuine objective rather than a sales proposition, the recipient has the institutional capacity to absorb and retain what is transferred, and both sides sustain the continuity of commitment required to allow results to materialise across the years it takes for a first-of-class construction programme to run its course. The India-France submarine partnership satisfied these conditions, and the fleet that is now in service is the evidence.

The Horizon 2047 framework extends this logic into domains beyond defence: space, digital infrastructure, climate cooperation, education and technology are all named in the roadmap’s scope. The defence relationship, however, provides the most fully developed model of what deep bilateral cooperation looks like in practice, because it is the domain where the two countries have worked together longest and at the greatest depth of technical engagement. What MDL and Naval Group built together across two decades is not only a fleet of submarines. It is a methodology: a demonstration of how India and France can work together when the objective is not delivery of a finished product but the building of a capability that India can sustain, develop and eventually surpass.

India’s approach to defence partnerships has always been shaped by the competing claims of genuine capability need and the preservation of strategic autonomy. The Scorpene programme represents a case in which both claims were satisfied over time, through a partnership in which the supplier’s commitment to India’s industrial growth was structural rather than rhetorical.

The Modi-Macron relationship has given that partnership its most visible political expression: the exchange of ceremonial honours at Bastille Day and Republic Day, the elevation to Special Global Strategic Partnership, the shared Horizon 2047 vision. These are significant diplomatic achievements. What gives them substance is what was built in Mumbai: six submarines, a trained Indian workforce, an institutional knowledge base at Mazagon Dock Shipbuilders, and the technical foundation for a next programme in which the submarine India builds will, in its essential systems, be the submarine India designed. That is what twenty-five years of unconditional partnership produces, and it is what the next twenty-five years, held to the same standard, will produce again.

Author

  • The author is a Subject Matter Expert on AI, Cyberwarfare and Cybersecurity at Centre for Joint Warfare Studies (CENJOWS), Ministry of Defence, Government of India, and serves as COO and Head of AI Strategy at IADN (Indian Aerospace & Defence News), New Delhi. The author holds a PhD on “AI and Security Policy ” from Jawaharlal Nehru University's School of International Studies, New Delhi and also served as a  Visiting Research Fellow at MGIMO University, Moscow.

    View all posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *